Review by Eleanor J. Bader
Sarah Vogel’s life has been a series of losses as well as lucky breaks. Her birth in Auschwitz coincided with her mother’s death, but women in the concentration camp did what they could to ensure her survival. Time in Birkenau and Bergen-Belsen followed. Then liberation, adoption by the Vogelmann family until, at 15, she is sent to live with someone new. Escape to Berlin came next, along with her first romantic encounter. Then, thanks to the Jewish Immigrant Resettlement Program, she met people whose job it was to help her find her way. At first, emigrating to Israel seemed alluring, but Sarah ultimately opted for the US. First, however, she gave birth to a daughter, conceived during a hasty hook-up with a Russian soldier.
For a time, she and Sasha lived in Queens, NY, where she found work as a custodian at a local college. A series of promotions, as well as an affair with a married professor, offered both heartbreak and opportunity, the upshot of which was a move to Ohio, where Sarah took an administrative job at Kent State. There, she married Walter, and together, they raised a family.
Becoming Sarah tells this fictional story, tracking four generations of Vogel women and covering more than 100 years, from Sarah’s birth in 1942 to the 100th anniversary of the end of the war in 2045. It’s a sweeping look at the Holocaust’s impact on successive generations, even when the actual facts of Sarah’s experience are neither discussed nor disclosed to her offspring or partners. It’s also an in-depth personality profile of an astoundingly passive — and simultaneously fatalistic, fierce, and independent — woman, someone who never hired a private investigator or tried to find Sasha after she vanished. It’s unclear why.
Becoming Sarah is an unusual and deeply moving peek into the aftermath of the Nazi Holocaust — leavened with occasional humor — about a flawed but believably-human protagonist and the positive and negative influence she cast on subsequent generations of family members.
Becoming Sarah by Diane Botnick. She Writes Press, October 2025.
Reviewer bio: Eleanor J. Bader is a Brooklyn, NY-based journalist who writes about books and domestic social issues for Truthout, Rain Taxi, The Progressive, Ms. Magazine, the Los Angeles Review of Books, and The Indypendent.
