Reflecting on Rejection
“Rejection doesn’t have to be the end of the line” according to Carve Magazine. To which end, they include the coolest column in each issue: Decline/Accept, with commentary from a writer whose work, originally declined by Carve, has been accepted elsewhere. The author writes about their rejection/revision/acceptance, a snippet of the original work is included with Carve editors’ comments as well the snippet revised (if applicable) along with editors’ comments from the publication that accepted the work.
The Summer 2018 issue features Kelly Hill, whose story “The Bearded Loon” was published in the July 2017 issue of Upstreet. Hill comments on the rejection and subsequent acceptance, “I’ve been doing this writing thing long enough to understand that the story I set out to tell is not always the story I write or the story that others ultimately read. I’m always thankful for good feedback from insightful readers, although any feedback can be useful if it helps you mentally justify your stylistic choices.”
Decline/Accept is a great craft component for readers and writers alike, and you can see a full listing with links out (when available) to the final published work here.